Quick Jay County IN MLS Search

Browse All Jay County IN Historical Properties for Sale

$239,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 202637351 MLS 1,348 SqFt. Matthew Hawkins
Welcome to Mardego Hills! This charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch is tucked away on a quiet, tree-lined street in Northwest Allen County Schools. Mature trees, a large backyard, and a spacious 2-car garage give this home plenty to love inside and out. Step inside to find hardwood floors in all three bedrooms and a cozy wood-burning fireplace that makes the living room especially inviting. The home offers an updated kitchen and two bathrooms, including one recently remodeled with new plumbing from the manifold to the fixtures. Numerous major improvements provide added peace of mind, including a new roof in 2026, fully encapsulated crawl space with vapor barrier, dehumidifier, French drains and sump pump, and updated plumbing. Additional updates include newer plumbing in the second bath, new hickory hardwood flooring in one bedroom, and refreshed landscaping. Outside, enjoy a large backyard with plenty of room to gather, play, grill or relax beneath the mature trees. The oversized attached 2-car garage provides excellent storage and space for all your tools or toys! All of this is located in a quiet, family-friendly neighborhood with convenient access to I-69 and I-469, shopping, dining, hospitals, and everything northwest Fort Wayne has to offer. A well-cared-for home with character, significant updates, and a setting that’s hard to beat!

11307 Gongwer Dr, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Matthew Hawkins from Wieland Real Estate. Cell: 260-417-2165

$388,500
4 Beds 4 Baths 202637265 MLS 2,610 SqFt. Jackie Clark
Located in the desirable Liberty Hills subdivision, this impressive 2,610 sq. ft. home sits proudly atop a hill on two lots totaling 1.48 acres, creating a commanding yet private setting. A long paved driveway winds up to the home, while a wooded perimeter surrounds the property with mature trees. The east side features an additional wooded area with a small creek meandering through, adding to the peaceful setting. Enjoy the feeling of being tucked away while remaining conveniently close to shopping, dining, the Lutheran Hospital campus, and Interstate 69. Inside, you’ll find 4 large bedrooms, 3.5 baths, and two spacious living areas connected by a double-sided gas fireplace, creating the perfect setting for everyday comfort and entertaining. The generously sized kitchen features Harlan cabinetry, Corian countertops, newer appliances, a breakfast bar, updated fixtures, and an adjoining dining area highlighted by a charming window seat. A beautiful 3-season room with tongue-and-groove paneling, a beamed cathedral ceiling, and an abundance of natural light offers additional flex space. Main-floor laundry and a conveniently located half bath add to the thoughtful layout. The primary suite is privately tucked away and features double closets and its own ensuite bath. Need even more space? The 1,092 sq. ft. partial basement is currently unfinished and offers excellent potential for future finished living space, recreation, hobbies, a home gym, or additional storage. An oversized side-load garage provides abundant parking and storage, while the 20' x 14' outbuilding is ideal for lawn equipment, gardening supplies, hobbies, and additional storage. Extensive updates enhance both the beauty and functionality of the home, including replacement of 13 windows, all-new gutters and downspouts, new soffit and house wrap, new shaker siding, and a new porch ceiling. Additional improvements include new flooring in the living room, hallways, bathrooms, and entryway, newer toilets in three bathrooms, updated kitchen fixtures, and a newer water heater. Washer & Dryer negotiable. Average Monthly Utilities (over a 12 month period): Nipsco Gas - $80.00 REMC:110.00 City Utilities (incl Trash): $55.00 Aqua Water: $35.00

9528 Saratoga Rd, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Jackie Clark from Coldwell Banker Real Estate Gr. Cell: 260-450-5545

$335,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 202636946 MLS 2,106 SqFt. Jenna Nelson
ANOTHER OPEN HOUSE ADDED DUE TO HIGH INTEREST! COME JOIN ME ON TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 15TH FROM 5-6. Imagine waking up every morning surrounded by nature, with OVER 5 acres to call your own! This property offers the space, privacy, and peaceful country setting you’ve been looking for, PLUS NO HOA!! From the comfort of your own home, you may catch glimpses of deer, wild turkeys, foxes, and more roaming the property. And with fall just around the corner, you can look forward to beautiful seasonal views right outside your door! Inside, there’s plenty of room for everyone with two spacious living areas, a den, two full bathrooms, and generously sized bedrooms throughout. The primary suite features double closets and an attached bathroom. Recent updates include HVAC, new windows, a new well, and new flooring in both bathrooms, giving you some great improvements while still leaving plenty of opportunity to add your own personal touches and make this home truly yours. The basement also features a workshop. Step outside and you’ll find a beautiful stamped concrete patio, perfect for morning coffee, summer gatherings, or relaxing around a fire with family and friends while taking in the peaceful surroundings. The 3-car garage offers plenty of room for vehicles, hobbies, and storage. It also has a large dog kennel. And here’s the best part — you can enjoy the peace and privacy of country living without giving up the convenience of nearby amenities! You’re less than 10 minutes from Georgetown Shopping Center and Chapel Ridge, putting shopping, dining, and everyday conveniences just a short drive away. If you’ve been dreaming of space to spread out, room to breathe, beautiful wildlife, and the convenience of being close to everything you need, this one is worth seeing! Properties with this much acreage and so much potential don’t come around often in this area. Come see it for yourself before someone else gets the chance to call it home!

11722 N River Rd, New Haven

Listing courtesy of Jenna Nelson from Coldwell Banker Real Estate Gr. Cell: 260-385-5235

$475,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 202635566 MLS 2,025 SqFt. Sierra Potts
Opportunities like this rarely become available on Tri Lakes. Set on over half an acre with water wrapping around nearly the entire property, this beautifully renovated 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch occupies one of the most remarkable lots on Round Lake. With expansive waterfront, a private beach area, pier, meticulous landscaping, and unforgettable sunset views, this is a property that leaves an impression the moment you arrive. Inside, nearly every space has been refreshed and thoughtfully updated. Brand new luxury vinyl plank flooring flows throughout the home alongside new trim and fresh paint, while the recently renovated primary bathroom adds another polished touch. The open concept kitchen, dining, and living areas create an inviting space for entertaining and everyday life, filled with abundant natural light. A window lined sunroom may quickly become your favorite room in the house, offering panoramic views of the water and surrounding landscape. Major improvements have already been handled, including a full tear off roof replacement approximately four years ago, a 2020 water heater, and HVAC installed in 2017. An attached one car garage is complemented by two additional sheds. The larger shed features electricity, attic storage, and a dedicated workbench area, while the second provides convenient storage for all the necessities of lake life. Step outside and it becomes easy to understand why properties like this are so rarely available. Round Lake is a peaceful non ski lake ideal for kayaking, fishing, swimming, and leisurely boat rides, with a nature preserve across the water creating a serene backdrop where deer and wildlife are frequent visitors. Round Lake also connects to Little Cedar and Big Cedar, giving you access to even more of the Tri Lakes experience, including daily ski time on Big Cedar from 1 to 4 PM. Tri Lakes is more than a place to live. It is a community people fall in love with and rarely want to leave. Golf carts are a favorite way to get around, neighbors know and help one another, and nearby favorites include Tri Lakes Park, Portside Pizza, and Big Eyed Fish overlooking the water. Community events, an incredible annual fireworks show, boating, sunsets, and summers on the lake make life here feel like a getaway without ever leaving home. Move in, slow down, and experience the kind of lake life that is increasingly difficult to find.

3245 E Colony Ave, Columbia City

Listing courtesy of Sierra Potts from North Eastern Group Realty. Cell: 260-229-2580

$649,999
2 Beds 2 Baths 202636658 MLS 2,546 SqFt. Brandon Ferrell
Welcome to a truly rare opportunity on Big Lake! A scenic, tree lined drive leads you back to the property, with beautiful mature trees on both sides creating a private and picturesque approach to the home. Offering over 2,500 square feet of living space, an incredible 2.78 acre lakefront setting, and stunning views across both Basin 1 and Basin 2, this property delivers the space, privacy, and lake lifestyle that are incredibly difficult to find. Even better, it is listed under appraised value! Step inside this spacious ranch and immediately appreciate a layout designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The living room is the heart of the home, featuring a cathedral ceiling, cozy fireplace, and gorgeous views of the lake. The kitchen offers plenty of J. Miller cabinetry, stainless steel appliances that remain, and an extended countertop that doubles as convenient seating for four with a granite top. The primary suite feels like a private retreat, featuring glass French doors that allow you to enjoy views toward the lake, vaulted ceilings, and a large walk in closet that also features a vaulted ceiling. The spacious primary bathroom includes a double sink vanity, separate area for the toilet, and lots of natural light from the overhead skylight. An additional flex room provides the perfect opportunity for a home office, hobby room, or potential third bedroom. The home also offers another spacious living area at the back of the home, complete with a two year old ductless HVAC system, creating even more room to spread out. A Generac home generator provides peace of mind, while the completely encapsulated crawlspace is another valuable improvement. Outside is where this property truly separates itself from the typical lake home. The attached two car garage and impressive 30x36 pole barn provide exceptional storage for vehicles, lake toys, equipment, and more. The nearly three acre setting offers a level of privacy and space that is rarely available on the water. The lakeside area is designed for enjoying everything Big Lake has to offer. A fenced area leads to steps and direct access to the pier, while the covered porch and lakeside awning create the perfect setting to enjoy dinner, drinks, and beautiful views. At 4951 S Channel Lane, you are not simply buying a lake house. You are buying acreage, privacy, exceptional water views, over 2,500 square feet of living space, abundant storage, and room for all your lake toys.

4951 S Channel Ln, Columbia City

Listing courtesy of Brandon Ferrell from Keller Williams Realty Group. bferrell@kw.com

$299,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 202636544 MLS 1,924 SqFt. Stacie Bellam-Fillman
Adorable character-filled home situated on a gorgeous .77-acre property! Located in desirable Southwest Fort Wayne, tucked away in a neighborhood just off Jefferson Boulevard, you’ll love this amazing location. From the moment you pull up, you’ll love the beautiful terracotta tile roof and charming curb appeal. The terracotta tile roof not only adds to the home’s incredible character, but is also known for exceptional longevity. Out back, enjoy your own private oasis with a huge yard, mature trees, and a walk-out deck with above-ground pool. Inside the home you’ll love the old house charm mixed with many updates. Some features include arched doorways, original hardwood floors, and a cozy living room with a fireplace and built-ins. The kitchen has been completely updated with new cabinetry, countertops, subway tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances, and a farmhouse apron-front sink. The main level also features one of the bedrooms and a beautifully updated full bathroom. Upstairs offers a charming loft area with built-ins (could be 4th bedroom), plus two additional bedrooms with an updated Jack-and-Jill bathroom featuring a double vanity. Additional highlights include an attached two-car garage with attached mudroom/breezeway into the house, full basement for storage & extra bonus space, plus 8-year-old furnace, central air, and water heater. This home has so much to offer in an amazing location—be sure to check it out!

4206 Hazelhurst Dr, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Stacie Bellam-Fillman from Orizon Real Estate, Inc.. Off: 260-248-8961

$999,900
7 Baths 202633745 MLS Jordan Wildman
Once-in-a-Lifetime Investment & Historic Masterpiece in Downtown Fort Wayne!First time on the market since 2007! This grand Greek Revival historic landmark—originally built by famed architect Henry Williams for Hugh McCulloch, who once served as the Secretary of the Treasury under Presidents Abraham Lincoln, Andrew Johnson and Chester Arthur—presents a truly rare acquisition opportunity. Rich in local history, this landmark property has evolved over the decades, having served as a distinguished private estate, the Fort Wayne College of Medicine, the Fort Wayne Turners, the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, and even a commercial retail space.Today, it is operating as a thriving, turnkey Airbnb featuring 5 units and 13 total bedrooms. Located right on the downtown edge, directly adjacent to the vibrant Riverfront development, Promenade Park, and just steps off the bustling Wells Street Corridor, the location couldn't be more prime.Key Property DetailsPrice / Availability: First time offered for sale since 2007Total Units: 5 Independent UnitsTotal Bedrooms: 13 BedroomsUnit Mix:Two 3-Bed / 2-Bath UnitsOne 3-Bed / 1-Bath UnitTwo 2-Bed / 1-Bath UnitsCondition: Undergone an immense amount of modern updates throughout while retaining its magnificent historic character.Parking: Ample on-site parking for residents and guests.Unmatched Versatility & Investment PotentialTurnkey Airbnb Operation: Generating income from day one as a short-term rental. Projected annual income to be $141,588 for 2026. House-Hacker’s Dream: Live in one of the spacious 3-bedroom units while the remaining 4 units cover your mortgage and expenses.Flexible Downtown Edge Zoning: Enjoy almost unlimited options for future use—whether continuing as short-term rentals, converting to long-term apartments, establishing commercial/retail space, or restoring it into an iconic private downtown estate.Turnkey Option Available: All furniture is included with a strong offer! (Additional personal property is TBD).Location HighlightsPromenade Park & Riverfront Development: Located immediately adjacent to Fort Wayne’s premier riverfront destination.Wells Street Corridor: Walking distance to local dining, boutique shopping, and nightlife.Downtown Edge: Seamless access to the heart of downtown Fort Wayne's commercial and entertainment districts.For detailed information on the extensive zoning opportunities, historical documents, and income.https://my.matterport.com/

616 W Superior St, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Jordan Wildman from eXp Realty, LLC. Home: 260-498-0384

$999,900
13 Beds 7 Baths 202633743 MLS 11,691 SqFt. Jordan Wildman
Once-in-a-Lifetime Investment & Historic Masterpiece in Downtown Fort Wayne! First time on the market since 2007! This grand Greek Revival historic landmark—originally built by famed architect Henry Williams for Hugh McCulloch, who once served as the Secretary of the Treasury under Presidents Abraham Lincoln, Andrew Johnson and Chester Arthur—presents a truly rare acquisition opportunity. Rich in local history, this landmark property has evolved over the decades, having served as a distinguished private estate, the Fort Wayne College of Medicine, the Fort Wayne Turners, the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, and even a commercial retail space. Today, it is operating as a thriving, turnkey Airbnb featuring 5 units and 13 total bedrooms. Located right on the downtown edge, directly adjacent to the vibrant Riverfront development, Promenade Park, and just steps off the bustling Wells Street Corridor, the location couldn't be more prime. Key Property DetailsPrice / Availability: First time offered for sale since 2007Total Units: 5 Independent Units Total Bedrooms: 13 Bedrooms Unit Mix: Two 3-Bed / 2-Bath Units One 3-Bed / 1-Bath Unit Two 2-Bed / 1-Bath Units Condition: Undergone an immense amount of modern updates throughout while retaining its magnificent historic character. Parking: Ample on-site parking for residents and guests. Unmatched Versatility & Investment Potential Turnkey Airbnb Operation: Generating income from day one as a short-term rental. Projected annual income to be $141,588 for 2026. House-Hacker’s Dream: Live in one of the spacious 3-bedroom units while the remaining 4 units cover your mortgage and expenses. Flexible Downtown Edge Zoning: Enjoy almost unlimited options for future use—whether continuing as short-term rentals, converting to long-term apartments, establishing commercial/retail space, or restoring it into an iconic private downtown estate. Turnkey Option Available: All furniture is included with a strong offer! (Additional personal property is TBD).Location Highlights Promenade Park & Riverfront Development: Located immediately adjacent to Fort Wayne’s premier riverfront destination. Wells Street Corridor: Walking distance to local dining, boutique shopping, and nightlife. Downtown Edge: Seamless access to the heart of downtown Fort Wayne's commercial and entertainment districts. For detailed information on the extensive zoning opportunities, historical documents, and income state

616 W Superior St, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Jordan Wildman from eXp Realty, LLC. Home: 260-498-0384

$999,900
13 Beds 7 Baths 202633744 MLS 11,691 SqFt. Jordan Wildman
Once-in-a-Lifetime Investment & Historic Masterpiece in Downtown Fort Wayne!First time on the market since 2007! This grand Greek Revival historic landmark—originally built by famed architect Henry Williams for Hugh McCulloch, who once served as the Secretary of the Treasury under Presidents Abraham Lincoln, Andrew Johnson and Chester Arthur—presents a truly rare acquisition opportunity. Rich in local history, this landmark property has evolved over the decades, having served as a distinguished private estate, the Fort Wayne College of Medicine, the Fort Wayne Turners, the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, and even a commercial retail space.Today, it is operating as a thriving, turnkey Airbnb featuring 5 units and 13 total bedrooms. Located right on the downtown edge, directly adjacent to the vibrant Riverfront development, Promenade Park, and just steps off the bustling Wells Street Corridor, the location couldn't be more prime.Key Property DetailsPrice / Availability: First time offered for sale since 2007Total Units: 5 Independent UnitsTotal Bedrooms: 13 BedroomsUnit Mix:Two 3-Bed / 2-Bath UnitsOne 3-Bed / 1-Bath UnitTwo 2-Bed / 1-Bath UnitsCondition: Undergone an immense amount of modern updates throughout while retaining its magnificent historic character.Parking: Ample on-site parking for residents and guests.Unmatched Versatility & Investment PotentialTurnkey Airbnb Operation: Generating income from day one as a short-term rental. Projected annual income to be $141,588 for 2026. House-Hacker’s Dream: Live in one of the spacious 3-bedroom units while the remaining 4 units cover your mortgage and expenses.Flexible Downtown Edge Zoning: Enjoy almost unlimited options for future use—whether continuing as short-term rentals, converting to long-term apartments, establishing commercial/retail space, or restoring it into an iconic private downtown estate.Turnkey Option Available: All furniture is included with a strong offer! (Additional personal property is TBD).Location HighlightsPromenade Park & Riverfront Development: Located immediately adjacent to Fort Wayne’s premier riverfront destination.Wells Street Corridor: Walking distance to local dining, boutique shopping, and nightlife.Downtown Edge: Seamless access to the heart of downtown Fort Wayne's commercial and entertainment districts.For detailed information on the extensive zoning opportunities, historical documents, and incomehttps://my.matterport.com/s

616 W Superior St, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Jordan Wildman from eXp Realty, LLC. Home: 260-498-0384

Start Your Search

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.


Jay County Historical Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Jay County and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!