Browse All LaGrange County IN Between $500K - $600K Properties for Sale

8 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202630216 MLS ⋅ 1,600 SqFt. ⋅ Jesse Riegsecker

AUCTION! This amazing 16+ acre property is set to sell at Phone Bid Auction on September 10th at 5pm! The posted starting bid is the starting bid not the buy it now price. This property has 2 houses on the property and is set up for horses or live stock with a large barn with boxes stalls and a large attached heated shop building. The main house has 3 bedroom and 2 baths with the large heated shop that also has a 2 bedroom 1 bath apartment. This building has in floor heat throughout and also a full HVAC unit. The second home is a 3 bedroom 2 bath and was completely remodeled in 2021. The property is perfect for those that enjoy the outdoors and hunting with plenty of wildlife and conveniently located across the road from Pigeon River Reserve (Mango) with 10,000+ acres of additional land to hunt and enjoy. Auction Open Houses are set for August 6&13&20&7 Sept 3 from 3-5pm.

3420 N 900 East, Howe

Listing courtesy of Jesse Riegsecker from Bright Star Real Estate Services LLC. office: 574-821-7653

$595,000

202620507 MLS ⋅ Michael Patka

THIS PROPERTY BEING OFFERED AT PHONE BID/ONLINE AUCTION WITH A STARTING BID OF $595,000! The Old Carriage Inn is a premium boutique lodging destination strategically positioned in the heart of Shipshewana’s entertainment and tourism corridor! This is far more than just a building — you are purchasing location, future cash flow, tourism demand, event traffic, and an established reputation. Located directly across from the Michiana Event Center, with a walking path to one of the largest flea markets in the United States, and just minutes from the nationally recognized Blue Gate Theatre entertainment district. This 11-room (plus owner’s 3-bedroom living quarters) boutique lodging property is perfectly positioned to capitalize on the region’s year-round tourism and event-driven economy. With large-group accommodations, walkable access to major attractions, and limited competing inventory of similar scale, the property offers exceptional revenue potential and strong long-term appreciation.

240 E Farver Street, Shipshewana

Listing courtesy of Michael Patka from Grogg Martin Realty. Offc: 260-350-7331

$579,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202620405 MLS ⋅ 2,158 SqFt. ⋅ Angela Harouff

OPEN HOUSE Sunday, MAY 31st 1PM-3PM Lakefront Luxury, Your Private Lake Oasis Awaits! Just in Time for Lake Season! Calling all lake lovers, whether you're dreaming of unforgettable summers on the water or embracing year-round lake living, this rare corner-lot retreat at the intersection of Westler & Witmer Lakes offers the perfect opportunity to own your own slice of paradise. Perfectly positioned on the channel with panoramic views of the main lake, this beautifully built, turn-key 3-bedroom, 2-bath home is flooded with natural light from every window. The open-concept design features granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, walk-in showers, 6-panel doors, and a tankless water heater — blending comfort, quality, and low-maintenance living. Step from the spacious living room onto the 20x10 elevated deck and soak in sweeping views of both the peaceful channel and the sparkling main lake. Morning coffee by the water, afternoons spent boating, sunset cruises, evenings around the fire, this is the lake lifestyle buyers wait for. There is even extra storage under the deck for all your water and boating toys. Plus, enjoy the convenience of local favorite Coody Brown’s restaurant just a short walk away, perfect for lakeside dining, live music, and gathering with friends and family after a day on the water. Upstairs, one bedroom offers access to a charming third-level bonus space perfect for a cozy hideaway, home office, or additional storage. The built-in security system and metal pier are included for added convenience and peace of mind. Located on the highly desirable Indian Chain of Lakes, you’ll enjoy access to 680 acres of year-round recreation, including all-sports Witmer and Dallas Lakes plus three additional fishing lakes. Quiet serenity in the back, endless lake fun in the front — truly the best of both worlds. Summer is almost here, and opportunities like this don’t last long. Imagine making this stunning property your own lake oasis and creating memories for years to come. Schedule your private showing today and bring your offer before lake season is in full swing! Home is supported by 27 helical pilings beneath the fully encapsulated concrete crawl space offering ample dry storage the size of the main floor. Crawl space access is located in the hallway closet.

1425 E 700 Road, Wolcottville

Listing courtesy of Angela Harouff from North Eastern Group Realty. Off: 260-489-7095

$589,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202619343 MLS ⋅ 2,844 SqFt. ⋅ Daniel Orlando

COME SEE THIS INCREDIBLE HOME ON DALLAS LAKE, LaGrange Indiana's premier ALL SPORTS sun-up to sun-down recreation lake. 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, sitting on just under half an acre with direct access to a ski lake. This is the first time this home has been offered in 30 years, tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac along the Indian Chain of Lakes. This ranch with a walkout basement offers about 150 feet of channel frontage, with easy access to Witmer, Westler, Hackenburg, and Messick Lakes. Built in 1993, it has 2,576 finished square feet and sits on a deep, wide and easy to navigate channel that you can leave your piers and boat lifts in all winter (BOAT LIFT EXCLUDED). Out back (street side), mature trees line the street leading to a semi-circle concrete driveway and a 3-car attached garage that’s finished and insulated. Out front (lakefront), the yard is big, level, and set up perfectly for yard games or just relaxing by the water. There’s also a 14x18 lakeside shed for all your gear, an included pier, and plenty of waterfront to enjoy with peek-a-boo lake views right from the property. Inside, the main level feels open and bright with 11-foot cathedral ceilings in the kitchen, living, and dining areas. The kitchen flows right into the main living space with a pass-through that keeps everything connected. Down the hall, the owner’s suite is spacious, with its own private bath, double closets, and a French door leading out to a large 16x20 deck overlooking the water. You’ll also find main-level laundry, a guest bedroom, and a half bath. The lower level opens up to a large entertainment space or flex room, complete with a custom Amish-built wet bar with beverage sink, and space for a full-size fridge that overlooks the pool table and entertainment center (which can stay if you want). Down the hall are two more bedrooms (one without a window), a full bath, and a 19x15 three-season room. A few other things worth noting: solid 2x6 construction, water views from most rooms, a newer AC (3 years old), furnace replaced in 2017, and all kitchen appliances plus washer and dryer are included. And since you’re on the channel, no need to pull your pier or boat lift out for the winter. BOAT LIFT IS EXCLUDED.

0205 W 600 S, Wolcottville

Listing courtesy of Daniel Orlando from Mike Thomas Associates. 260-463-2881

$500,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202617369 MLS ⋅ 1,368 SqFt. ⋅ Debbie Lucyk

The best lot on the West side Adams Lake with prime 80 feet of lakefront. Adams Lake is a sought-after ski lake known for excellent fishing and boating. The entire lake can be seen from this lot. Breath taking views of sunrise and moon rise. This double lot includes a 161' x 80' lakefront parcel plus an additional 111' x 40' back lot, offering exceptional development potential. The lakefront is shallow with a sandy beach, ideal for swimming and family enjoyment. The existing home has not been used a summer cottage for approximately 10 years. The property is best suited as a tear-down to maximize value. Zoning and lot configuration present a rare opportunity for potential development of two homes, each with stunning lake views and walk-out basements. An outstanding chance to build your dream lakefront retreat or investment property in a highly desirable location. Annual taxed based on all 6 parcels. Acreage is the combination of all parcels. Adams lake is 308 Acres offers a sand bar and all sports recreation from 10 a.m. - 6:00 p.m. Natural lake that is spring fed.

6105 S 455 E, Wolcottville

Listing courtesy of Debbie Lucyk from CENTURY 21 Bradley Realty, Inc. Cell: 260-466-3987

$525,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202613981 MLS ⋅ 1,302 SqFt. ⋅ Heather Culler

**BACK ON THE MARKET AT NO FAULT OF THE SELLERS**Experience the best of Northeast Indiana lake living on Big Turkey Lake—an all-sports lake known for its recreation and natural beauty. Nestled in the peaceful setting of Turtle Cove, this property offers a rare combination of privacy and scenic views, with abundant wildlife and calm waters perfect for paddle boarding, kayaking, and swimming. An added bonus of the cove location: no need to remove your pier and lift seasonally, offering convenience and extended enjoyment of your waterfront. This well-appointed home features 3 bedrooms, including a conveniently located primary suite on the main floor. The open-concept layout creates a seamless flow between living, dining, and kitchen spaces, while engineered hardwood flooring throughout adds warmth and a refined touch. Additional highlights include a 2-car attached garage and thoughtfully designed outdoor living spaces. A spacious composite deck provides durability and low-maintenance enjoyment, ideal for relaxing or entertaining. Down by the water, a charming pergola creates the perfect gathering spot to take in the tranquil surroundings. Whether you're seeking a year-round residence or a weekend retreat, this property captures the essence of lake life—peaceful, active, and inviting. Lake life is calling—don’t miss your chance to answer.

11990 E 395 S, Lagrange

Listing courtesy of Heather Culler from Mike Thomas Associates. OFF: 260-668-8877

$529,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202610472 MLS ⋅ 1,226 SqFt. ⋅ Noel Frost

Welcome to a rare opportunity to own 120 feet of pristine lakefront on the highly sought-after Fish Lake—your private sanctuary on a .68-acre estate-sized lot. This fully remodeled, like-new brick home delivers the effortless, turn-key lake lifestyle discerning buyers expect, paired with the privacy and space that are increasingly hard to find. A 30x40, 1200 sq ft finished pole building expands your living and entertaining possibilities—perfect for hosting gatherings, storing luxury lake toys, or creating the ultimate hobby or recreation space. Inside, the home has been completely transformed with new metal roofing, drywall, lighting, flooring, doors, fixtures, HVAC, and electrical—a true modern rebuild. The designer kitchen features quartz countertops, soft-close cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, custom backsplash, and elegant lighting. The open living and dining area is wrapped in panoramic vinyl windows, showcasing unobstructed southern-exposure lake views and anchored by a cozy fireplace. The lakefront primary suite includes a beautifully updated bathroom with a double vanity and tub/shower surround. Two additional bedrooms and a second updated bath provide comfort for guests. Step outside to a covered porch overlooking a sweeping lakefront lawn, sandy beach area, fire pit, and endless space for outdoor living. A rare 5-ft cement crawlspace offers exceptional storage and storm shelter security. With two connected lakes ideal for paddleboarding, kayaking, swimming, and fishing, this is the turn-key luxury lake property you’ve been waiting for.

5120 E 100 S Road, Lagrange

Listing courtesy of Noel Frost from Coldwell Banker Real Estate Gr. Cell: 260-585-4112

$525,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202607393 MLS ⋅ 3,528 SqFt. ⋅ Cynthia Trapp

JUST REDUCED - AND NOW INCLUDES A 1 YR HOME WARRANTY FOR PEACE OF MIND. Nestled along the serene shores of Stone Lake in LaGrange County, this stunning newer-construction, three-level home offers the rare combination of move-in-ready convenience and exceptional waterfront living near Shipshewana, IN. Whether you're searching for a year-round Stone Lake residence or a premier lakefront retreat in Northern Indiana, this meticulously maintained property impresses from the moment you arrive. Step inside to discover rich maple hardwood flooring and a bright, open-concept main level where vaulted ceilings soar overhead and a wall of windows frames breathtaking lake views. A cozy wood stove anchors the living space, creating a warm and inviting gathering spot in every season. Sliding doors open to an elevated three-season porch and aluminum deck complete with a power awning — the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee, host summer evenings, or simply breathe in the lake air with a good book close at hand. The home's flexible three-level layout adapts beautifully to any lifestyle. The lower entry level features a spacious mudroom, a bedroom that doubles as a fun game room, and generous storage throughout. The upper loft level offers an inspiring setting for a home office, artist's studio, reading nook, or guest retreat. Spacious rooms and abundant closets throughout ensure that organization comes naturally and everything has its place. Just across the street, approximately 50 feet of private lake frontage on quiet, no-wake Stone Lake awaits — complete with a dock, firepit, and comfortable seating. Known for its calm, glassy waters, Stone Lake is a year-round playground for kayaking, canoeing, paddleboarding and fishing, all just steps from your front door. Outside, this property was intentionally designed for low-maintenance living. Retaining walls, perennial landscaping, and a charming pet-friendly fenced backyard make outdoor upkeep a breeze — while raised organic garden beds and a rainwater collection system are a dream come true for the green-thumbed enthusiast. A large heated workshop with electric provides exceptional space for hobbies, projects, lake gear storage, or a one-of-a-kind hangout spot. The attached two-car garage adds everyday convenience, and a whole-home generator ensures peace of mind no matter what the weather brings. This Stone Lake gem is located just minutes from the shops, restaurants and one-of-a-kind attractions of Shipshewana.

7185 N 1150 W Road, Shipshewana

Listing courtesy of Cynthia Trapp from Cressy & Everett - South Bend. Cell: 269-849-5947

$530,000

202606829 MLS ⋅ Noel Frost

Opportunities are abundant in this Retail/Office C-1 property that has been stylishly restored to accommodate your New Business while already having a tenant for instant rental income that generates $63,000 per year. Located on the high traffic State Rd 120, just 5 miles from the 80/90 Toll Road Interchange, and 10 miles from downtown Shipshewana. This location gives patrons/clients easy access to this stunning Commercial property that has established multiple shops/rental spaces/events and is now ready for you to build your Dream business. The white building was once a hotel and has a grand staircase, beautiful fixtures, and an upstairs ready for you to finish off for apartments, offices, or potential VRBO's. There is also a 30x40 barn that was used as a Pottery Studio, has water, heat & electrical with 4 hook ups for kilns available, or can be transformed into your vision for Events, parties, or storage on the .72 acre lot. Plenty of parking in the front & back, this property is in the Heart of Howe, surrounded by Restaurants, Shops, and across from the Town Park. Close to area lakes, 2 campgrounds, golf courses, and parks for a destination not just a business.

409 Third Street, Howe

Listing courtesy of Noel Frost from Coldwell Banker Real Estate Gr. Cell: 260-585-4112

Start Your Search

IDX information is provided by the Indiana Regional MLS and is exclusively for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Last updated

Between $500K - $600K LaGrange County Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $500k - $600k properties available in LaGrange County and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!