Quick Jay County IN MLS Search

Browse All Jay County IN Historical Properties for Sale

$186,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 202619663 MLS 1,409 SqFt. Christopher O'Connell
Listed well below the recent appraised value, this freshly renovated, move-in ready, 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers 1,409 square feet of thoughtfully updated living space in the heart of Fort Wayne. Every detail has been carefully reimagined to blend modern comfort with lasting quality, creating a clean and inviting atmosphere from the moment you enter through the door. The kitchen showcases stunning stone countertops that elevate everyday cooking into something special. The upstairs bathroom features an elegant tiled walk-in shower, delivering a touch of spa-like luxury right where you need it most. Major upgrades completed in 2025 mean years of worry-free living ahead. A brand-new roof protects your investment from the elements, while a new HVAC system ensures year-round comfort no matter what Indiana weather throws your way. Out back, a newly constructed garage provides secure parking and valuable storage space. The location perfectly balances peaceful residential living with convenient access to everything Fort Wayne has to offer. Enjoy nearby Ivan Lebamoff Reservoir Park or Hanna Homestead Park. Explore the stunning Foellinger-Freimann Botanical Conservatory, catch a game at Parkview Field, enjoy a coney dog at Fort Wayne's Famous Coney Island, or browse the shelves at Allen County Public Library — all just minutes from your front door. This property may qualify for lender-sponsored grants and/or down payment assistance programs. Contact your lender for eligibility requirements and details.

522 E Masterson Ave, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Christopher O'Connell from F.C. Tucker Fort Wayne.

$2,800,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 202611322 MLS 1,175 SqFt. David Weigand
Unique opportunity to own two parcels totaling 11 acres in a prime location in growing Leo and northwest Fort Wayne, offering exceptional flexibility for residential, business, or investment use. The primary 10.2-acre parcel features a 1,200 sq ft, three-bedroom ranch alongside a large flex building with recently expanded office space—ideal for a home-based business, workshop, or operations hub. The main barn features all concrete floors, providing durability and versatility for a variety of uses. Three expansive pole barns offer substantial capacity for equipment, materials, or tenant use. The main building is fully linked to the middle barn (Building 3), enhancing functionality for operations and communications. The home and buildings on this parcel are currently producing rental income, with existing leases that include a tree service, communications company, residential tenant, and additional storage rentals—delivering immediate cash flow for the next owner. A well-maintained pond adds both functionality and scenic appeal. The second parcel, spanning 0.8 acres, includes its own three-bedroom ranch with a separate driveway—well-suited for multi-generational living, guest accommodations, or additional rental income. With strong potential for construction operations, specialized storage and logistics, future residential development, or even a wedding/event venue, this property offers a rare combination of location, acreage, infrastructure, and income-producing capability. This property currently houses a business conducting active operations, therefore earliest possession is July 1st. The property will be clear of all equipment in the coming months.

15514 Tonkel Rd, Leo

Listing courtesy of David Weigand from Encore Sotheby's International Realty.

$695,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 202619603 MLS 5,103 SqFt. Sam Hartman
Many inspections already completed and available! This rare property is one of a kind, with its large farmhouse, 3.78 acres of land and multiple outbuildings. Whether you are looking for a private country retreat, multi-generational living, space for a home business, or incredible hobby and workshop space, this property delivers opportunities that are difficult to recreate. Sitting on 3.78 acres with a 0.7 acre stocked fishing pond, this property offers the peace and privacy of rural living while still providing convenient access to Highway 30 and I-469. The 1866 farmhouse immediately captures your attention with its large wraparound front porch, natural oak woodwork, and timeless farmhouse charm. While full of character, this home has already been brought into the modern era. Approximately 20 years ago, the home was gutted to the studs and updated with modern drywall, plumbing, and electrical while preserving the warmth and craftsmanship that make older homes so special. One of the most unique features of this property is the flexibility of its living spaces. The main home features a spacious kitchen, den, huge great room, 4 bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, and main level laundry. The finished basement functions almost like a second residence with its own full kitchen, bedroom, full bathroom, laundry hookups, and multiple living spaces ideal for guests, extended family, or independent living. The detached 60x36 four-car garage is connected to the home through an underground tunnel and includes a second-floor apartment complete with kitchen, living room, bedroom, and full bathroom. Two garage bays feature radiant heated floors. The outbuildings are equally impressive. The 70x40 shop includes its own 400 amp 3-phase electrical service on a separate meter, 20x40 overhead 2-ton crane, water heater, exhaust fans, airlines throughout, 3 overhead doors, and an upper-level office and man cave space. An additional 32x28 outbuilding provides even more room for storage and recreational use. Properties with this much land, infrastructure, flexibility, and character are incredibly rare. 13002 US Highway 30 E is more than just a home. It is a property built for big ideas and endless possibilities.

13002 Us Hwy 30 E, New Haven

Listing courtesy of Sam Hartman from Coldwell Banker Real Estate Gr. Cell: 260-312-7302

$150,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 202609860 MLS 1,272 SqFt. Warren Barnes
REDUCED PRICE TO SELL QUICKLY! Welcome home to 2315 California Avenue, a charming 3 bedroom, 1.5 bathroom, 2 story home nestled in the heart of 46805. With 1,272sqft of living space, this residence perfectly blends timeless character, modern potential, and the energy of city living. Step through the welcoming foyer entry and feel the warmth of original craftsmanship throughout plus a recently updated full bathroom! Crown molding, arched doorways, and natural woodwork give each room a sense of history and charm. The inviting living room features hardwood flooring and exposed wood ceilings, creating a cozy and elegant atmosphere. Flow seamlessly into the dining area, where you can easily imagine gatherings with friends and family, and then into a bright kitchen complete with a dishwasher and gas range. Upstairs, 3 comfortable bedrooms provide plenty of natural light and space to make your own. The home also features a full unfinished basement, ideal for storage or future finishing possibilities. With 100 amp service and an electric water heater, this home is ready for your personal touch—whether you’re looking for your next residence or an excellent investment opportunity in one of Fort Wayne’s most desirable urban neighborhoods. Step outside to enjoy your privacy fenced backyard, complete with alley access and a detached garage for convenient off-street parking. The rear home entry adds additional flexibility for everyday living. The location truly enhances the appeal of this home. Enjoy close proximity to Northside Park, Lakeside Park, Klug Park, and Allen County War Memorial Coliseum. Whether you’re a first-time buyer, an investor seeking potential, or someone who loves classic architecture with character and convenience, 2315 California Avenue is ready to welcome you home! Inspections are okay and seller prefers to sell as-is. This home is eligible for no money down conventional financing with no PMI and is also eligible for a grant up to $10,000 for closing costs, home inspections and appraisal. For more information, please ask.

2315 California Ave, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Warren Barnes from North Eastern Group Realty. Cell: 260-438-5639

$179,900
4 Beds 3 Baths 202620521 MLS 1,840 SqFt. Gregory Brown
*Maintenance-free living awaits in the highly sought-after Woodhurst Condominiums! *This beautifully updated two-story condo is one of the finest in the community, offering the perfect combination of comfort, convenience, and value. *The HOA takes care of the essentials, with monthly dues covering water, gas, trash, landscaping, lawn care, exterior maintenance, and access to outstanding community amenities. *The only utility you'll pay is electric. *Inside, you'll find 4 spacious bedrooms, 2 1/2 updated baths, and a thoughtfully designed floor plan that's ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. *The main level features a welcoming living room with a beautiful fireplace, a spacious kitchen, a separate dining room, and a private den that offers the perfect flex space for a home office or cozy retreat. *Sliding glass doors open to a private, fenced patio—perfect for relaxing or outdoor dining. *Upstairs, the generous primary suite features a beautifully tiled walk-in shower, while two additional oversized bedrooms and a fully updated guest bath provide plenty of space for family and guests. *Residents enjoy exceptional amenities, including a clubhouse, swimming pool, landscaped courtyard, and meticulously maintained grounds. *The home also includes off-street parking with a covered carport and a private 4' x 11' storage area for added convenience. *For added peace of mind, the furnace and central air conditioning were both replaced in 2024. *This move-in-ready home offers low-maintenance living in one of the area's most desirable condominium communities.

5511 S Wayne Ave, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Gregory Brown from CENTURY 21 Bradley Realty, Inc. Cell: 260-602-5297

$249,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 202619889 MLS 1,498 SqFt. Nathaniel Hicks
Welcome to a timeless brick home nestled in the heart of Fort Wayne's sought-after West Central neighborhood. Just moments from Electric Works, Promenade Park, Parkview Field, local restaurants, coffee shops, festivals, and everything downtown has to offer, this home places you in one of the city's most vibrant and walkable communities while still providing a peaceful place to call home. Inside, you'll find nearly 2,000 square feet of living space filled with the craftsmanship and character that make historic homes so special. Soaring ceilings, beautiful period woodwork, and architectural details create an inviting atmosphere throughout. The formal dining room features an intricate tin ceiling, while the living room is highlighted by a stunning coffered ceiling, offering spaces that are equally suited for everyday living and entertaining. Upstairs, the spacious full bathroom features a double vanity with convenient access from both bedrooms, blending modern functionality with the home's historic appeal. The detached two-car garage provides excellent parking and storage, while the finished upper level offers valuable bonus space for seasonal storage, hobbies, or whatever best fits your needs. Whether you're enjoying coffee on the welcoming front porch, relaxing in the private backyard, or taking a short stroll to some of Fort Wayne's favorite destinations, this home offers a lifestyle that's difficult to replicate. Rich in character, full of history, and perfectly positioned in one of the city's most beloved neighborhoods, this is a home you'll be proud to call your o

1124 W Jefferson Blvd, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Nathaniel Hicks from Real Broker, LLC.

$89,900
4 Beds 2 Baths 202618627 MLS 1,685 SqFt. Jerry Starks
Conveniently located near downtown, this duplex presents an incredible opportunity for investors, flippers, or owner-occupants looking to build equity and customize a property from the ground up. The owner has already taken the property all the way down to the studs, giving you a clean slate to design and finish exactly how you envision. With the major demolition already completed, you can move directly into rebuilding and installing all new electrical, plumbing, HVAC, windows, finishes, and other updates to create a modern income-producing property. Basement walls are solid, and the property offers strong upside potential for the right buyer. Plans and blueprints are available to help guide the design and layout, while still allowing flexibility to customize the duplex to your liking. Estimated rental income after completion is approximately $1,300–$1,500 per side, with an estimated after-repair value around $240,000–$250,000. The owner is a licensed contractor and may be willing to discuss completing the renovation for the buyer. FHA 203(k) financing could be a fantastic option — live in one unit while renting the other to help offset your mortgage payment. The possibilities are endless. Don’t miss this opportunity to create value and build wealth with a duplex in a convenient downtown location.

462 E Suttenfield St, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Jerry Starks from JM Realty Associates, Inc.. Cell: 260-479-8161

$575,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 202629542 MLS 3,318 SqFt. Jennifer Jenson
Tucked away on a private, wooded lot of over an acre, this stunning tri-level offers gorgeous curb appeal and 3,318 square feet of living space with a walkout lower level and a 4-Car Garage. Step inside the foyer and through to an expansive living room, where windows overlook the woods and a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace sets the tone. The updated kitchen is a showstopper — soft green cabinetry, quartz counters, and a huge island with a butcher block top and bar seating perfect for gathering. The eat-in kitchen welcomes you with its own cozy pellet stove. A new attractive metal roof was installed in 2022. Upstairs you'll find four spacious bedrooms and two full baths, including one bedroom with a custom-built bed that kids will love, and another that works well as a home office with hidden shelving. Storage abounds throughout this level. The walkout lower level impresses with a second floor-to-ceiling brick fireplace, a full wall of built-in cabinets, shelving and media center. A full bath and laundry area complete the space, along with a flexible bonus room featuring its own exterior entrance — ideal as a craft room, home office, or fifth bedroom.Take in the wooded scenery from the enclosed four-seasons room, or head outside to enjoy the two patios. The driveway offers plenty of parking, plus a secondary gravel driveway that leads to the back side of the garage. The oversized 4-car garage includes a half bath and a rear service door for lawn equipment, outdoor gear or your pet. Above the garage, accessible from the eat-in kitchen, awaits with over 1,000 SF of untapped potential, already roughed in for a bathroom and equipped with its own HVAC system, ready to become an in-law suite, studio, or whatever you envision. Peacefully secluded yet close to everything you need, this is a home where every day feels like a getaway.

1535 Wood Moor Dr, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Jennifer Jenson from RE/MAX Results. Cell: 310-428-7704

$260,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 202609375 MLS 1,734 SqFt. Karah Ellington
Welcome home to this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath gem, perfectly situated on Dodge Ave in the highly sought-after 05 neighborhood—known for its historic charm and walkable streets. Step inside to a spacious living room, flowing into a formal dining room accented by elegant glass doors—ideal for entertaining or quiet evenings at home. The main level also features 2 bonus rooms offering flexible space for additional living areas--the perfect retreat for plant lovers, creatives, or anyone craving a bright, uplifting space. Thoughtful updates throughout, including an updated kitchen with modern countertops, Whirlpool appliances, stylish vanities, and 2 full baths, one with a tile shower surround. The other tub/shower combo. Full basement, and the home includes a washer and dryer plus a rare and convenient laundry chute from all levels. Closets throughout the home are nicely sized and thoughtfully laid out, offering plenty of room for clothing, storage, and organization—an especially rare and welcome feature in a home of this era. Outside, enjoy the ease off-street parking with a private driveway and great bonus storage with the 2 car garage. A newer hot water heater (2023) All of this in a prime location—walking distance from shopping, schools, restaurants, and yes… ICE CREAM—making everyday living both convenient and delightful. This is historic neighborhood living with modern comfort.

2141 Dodge Ave, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Karah Ellington from CENTURY 21 Bradley Realty, Inc. Cell: 770-846-6664

$1,200,000
7 Beds 5 Baths 202621015 MLS 8,318 SqFt. Baylee McMaken
A gem in West Central! Known as “The Bishop Noll Mansion,” this stunning stucco estate—set on one of West Central’s largest lots—offers the convenience of city living with peaceful park views. Located on the Swinney Park Triangle near the tennis courts, it’s a short walk to restaurants, Parkview Stadium, Electric Works, and more. The River Greenway Trail is across the street, and Fort Wayne’s premier outdoor shopping, dining, and entertainment are just minutes away. Inside, you’ll find thick walls, crisp dentil molding, standout fixtures, beautiful leaded glass, and custom window treatments throughout. The foyer opens to the living room, dining room, and grand main staircase. The living room features built-in bookshelves, a fireplace with a tile surround, and two sets of leaded-glass French doors. The dining room flows into a wraparound four-season room with three sets of large leaded-glass French doors—an exceptional, light-filled space for entertaining. Conveniently located off the home’s attached two-car garage, the kitchen was recently remodeled with custom cabinetry by Kennebec Company, known for their ability to replicate cabinetry from the past, along with high-end appliances—adding modern function while respecting the home’s historic character. A second staircase off the kitchen leads to the laundry room. Upstairs, two French doors open to a bright vestibule and the home’s chapel. Marble columns and floors, an ornately carved ceiling, stained-glass windows, intricately carved cherry pews, and red velvet kneeling benches make this space truly breathtaking.The spacious primary suite includes the home’s second fireplace along with original built-in cabinetry. The primary bath feels brand new, with a glass walk-in shower, heated floors, and a beautiful vanity. A fully remodeled Jack-and-Jill bath (thoughtfully matched to the home’s historic style) sits between Bedrooms 2 and 3. Down the extended hallway over the garage are Bedrooms 4, 5, and 6, plus a changing room that could serve as Bedroom 7, along with another remodeled full bath. The finished daylight basement includes a family room, the home’s third fireplace, a full bath, a fitness room with a whirlpool and sauna, and a workshop with exposed brick and concrete floors. Beautiful wood floors run throughout the home, with new basement carpet and tile in the bathrooms. This West Central showpiece is a must-see.

1415 W Washington Blvd, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Baylee McMaken from ADT Realty. Cell: 260-740-4080

$1
12 Beds 6 Baths 202630119 MLS 5,997 SqFt. James Fanger
Auction Link: https://foreclosureauctions.com/properties/779 A rare opportunity to own a 6-unit multifamily property in one of the city’s most sought-after historic neighborhoods & location. Step into the character of a Historic Downtown multifamily home. Nearly 6,000 sq ft of living space, a grand covered porch, and finished basement units create a unique blend of charm and functionality. Surrounded by century-old homes, architectural landmarks and tree-lined streets, this asset offers strong rental demand, stable income, and long-term appreciation potential. Opportunity & Potential await the skilled homeowner or investor. Start improving your investment with updating & repairing the vacant units (4) & exterior and see your cash flow start on those too as you place your new tenants as you wish. The 2 occupied units can work with you on the future of those after closing. Tenants enjoy the walkable lifestyle—just moments from shops, restaurants, and entertainment—while investors benefit from steady occupancy and desirable neighborhood appeal & location of the downtown social & business district among other opportunities. This asset offers strong rental demand, stable income, and possible long-term appreciation potential. Property sold as-is, where-is. Taxes may change based on exemptions or lack thereof. Take a look today & register to bid your best cash offer by the end of the Auction.

817 W Wayne St, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of James Fanger from Cash For Keys, LLC.

$300,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 202623832 MLS 1,940 SqFt. Sue Teasdale
Tucked away on a beautifully landscaped .8 acre lot, this inviting property offers the ideal blend of privacy, comfort, and space to enjoy both indoors and out. Set well back from the road, the home enjoys a peaceful setting while still offering an expansive backyard with mature trees, established landscaping, and plenty of room to relax, garden, entertain, or simply enjoy nature. Inside, you'll find 1,940 square feet of above-grade living space featuring 4 bedrooms and 2.5 baths. The stunning 4-season room is truly the heart of the home, showcasing wood ceilings, walls of windows, and panoramic views of the gorgeous yard—making it a wonderful place to enjoy every season Indiana has to offer. The home offers multiple living spaces, including a cozy family room with a striking brick fireplace and built in shelves as well as a a spacious living room and formal dining room, ideal for gatherings or quiet evenings at home. The kitchen provides abundant cabinetry, generous work areas, and a practical layout designed for everyday living. You will appreciate the versatility of the oversized 30' x 26' garage complete with a dedicated workshop area. An additional storage shed with electricity provides even more space for projects, tools, or gardening equipment. With all the living space conveniently above grade, this lovingly cared-for home combines timeless character, exceptional outdoor living, and the kind of setting that rarely becomes available. Come for the yard, stay for the four-season room! (Monthly Utilities: Water is from the well, so none; Sewer is around $90; From 9/25-7/26 Gas averaged $56 and Electric averaged $137)

9714 Muldoon Rd, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Sue Teasdale from Coldwell Banker Real Estate Gr. Cell: 260-602-5022

$179,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 202629290 MLS 1,312 SqFt. Shawn Browning
Step into this beautifully updated two story home ideally located just minutes from the energy of downtown Fort Wayne, the beloved Fort Wayne Children's Zoo, and a short drive to premier shopping at Jefferson Pointe and Glenbrook Square. Inside, you will find 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms in a thoughtfully remodeled layout designed for comfort and everyday living. The main floor primary suite is a true retreat, featuring its own private entrance to a fully enclosed outdoor living space that is perfect for quiet mornings or relaxing evenings. The fully fenced backyard offers a welcoming space for entertaining, pets, or simply unwinding outdoors. Out front, the brand new porch and entrance deck create standout curb appeal and a warm first impression. The large unfinished basement provides incredible flexibility and could easily serve as additional living space, a hobby area, or workshop. It already includes a built in workbench and abundant storage. The kitchen comes equipped with newer stainless steel appliances including the range and oven, microwave, and dishwasher, all of which remain with the home. There is also generous off street parking for at least three vehicles right out front. Beautifully updated, perfectly located, and full of potential, this is a home you will not want to miss.

1117 3rd St, Fort Wayne

Listing courtesy of Shawn Browning from ERA Crossroads. Cell: 260-241-7181

Start Your Search

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.


Jay County Historical Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Jay County and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!